Cart
0
The first single-digit mornings arrived this week, right on schedule, and with them a question men tend to ask us sideways, as though it carried more risk than a double-breasted suit: how to wear a turtleneck. There is usually a qualifier attached — without looking like I'm trying something. We understand the hesitation. The roll neck drags more baggage behind it than anything else we sell. It is the collar of film directors, Bond villains, and that one architect at every dinner party. It is also, we would argue, the most useful thing a man in this city can put on between now and April. The fitting room keeps proving it.
How to wear a turtleneck under a jacket
Start where it earns its keep. When the tie left the office, it took something with it: the finished V between the lapels. An open shirt collar fills that space adequately. A fine roll neck fills it completely — a clean column of wool that frames the face and reads as deliberate from the far end of a boardroom, which an open collar never quite manages. Our strongest version this fall is a light knit under a dark jacket. The Stenströms light beige merino roll neck ($315) under charcoal flannel or a dark brown sport jacket does what a white shirt used to do: it puts light near your face and lets the tailoring stay serious.
One rule about the jacket, and we hold this line. A turtleneck belongs with texture — flannel, hopsack, a knitted jacket — not with a sharp worsted suit. Worsted plus roll neck is a 1974 annual-report portrait, and no one has pulled it off since. Keep the suit with its shirt. Give the roll neck to the jackets with some wool in their voice.
Gauge is the whole game
Fine merino, fourteen-gauge or close to it, sits under a lapel like a shirt. That is the kind to buy first, and the kind we reach for when a client wants to retire the tie without losing the finish. The chunky roll neck — and we keep Stenströms' navy and black chunky merinos on the wall for exactly this — is a different garment with the same name. It belongs over things, under a coat, out on a Saturday when the wind comes down Décarie with intent. Ask it to live under a tailored shoulder and the jacket loses: the sleeves crease, the collar bunches, the whole idea collapses into bulk. The test is simple. Under a jacket, the knit should be thin enough that from ten feet someone might take it for a shirt.
The mock neck, for the man who isn't sure
Half the men who ask us about turtlenecks leave with a mock neck instead, and they are not wrong to. The collar stands shorter and doesn't fold, which removes the theatre while keeping the warmth and the finished neckline. It is the half step, and we have argued for half steps all season. The one we keep reaching for is Patrick Assaraf's denim blue nano cashmere quarter-zip mock neck ($495) — cashmere where it touches the neck, a zip that gives the temperature of the day a vote, and a colour that behaves under navy, gray, and this season's browns alike. If the full roll neck feels like a statement you haven't rehearsed, start here. Nobody has ever accused a mock neck of trying something.
Fit, and one honest warning
Fit first. The collar should stand against the neck without gripping it — you are being framed, not strangled — and fold once, cleanly, if it folds at all. The body should skim; a billowing roll neck under a jacket reads as borrowed. And watch the sleeves, because no shirt cuff is coming to their rescue. Knit sleeves end at the wrist bone, full stop.
The warning is about heat, not style. A turtleneck is a commitment to wool at your throat for ten hours, and Montreal offices run their radiators like it's a competition. The knit that feels perfect on a minus-two walk to work is a sauna by ten o'clock indoors. This is the practical case for fine gauge over heft: a jacket can always go over thin merino, and come off again. There is nothing graceful to be done with a chunky roll neck in an overheated meeting.
If you have never worn one, don't decide at the rack. Bring the jacket you'd wear it under — or book a few minutes with us and borrow one of ours — and let the mirror settle it. It usually takes thirty seconds. And if the roll neck turns out not to be your collar, we will say so plainly and point you to the mock neck; the rest of the knit wall is here on Décarie either way. The tie isn't coming back to most floors in this city. The collar that replaced it deserves to be chosen on purpose.
